One thing that separates Irish Dancing to other forms of competition is its unique scoring system.
In Beginner competitions without Premierships, there is normally only one adjudicator (ADCRG). So scoring is straight forward, the dancer with the highest marks wins.
In Premierships there are normally two ADCRG and so this is when the marking system differs.
I am going to try to explain it. … Boy this is scary.
| Dancer |
Judge
1 |
Judge
2 |
| 1 |
164 |
180 |
| 2 |
168 |
172 |
| 3 |
166 |
184 |
| 4 |
158 |
168 |
| 5 |
156 |
174 |
| 6 |
162 |
176 |
| Place |
1st |
2nd |
3rd |
4th |
5th |
6th |
7th |
8th |
9th |
10th |
11th |
12th |
13th |
14th |
| Place Points Awarded |
100 |
75 |
65 |
60 |
56 |
53 |
50 |
47 |
45 |
43 |
41 |
39 |
38 |
37 |
Dancer Judge
1 Judge
2 1 164 -
3rd 180 -
2nd 2 168 -
1st 172 -
5th 3 166 -
2nd 184 -
1st 4 158 -
5th 168 -
6th 5 156 -
6th 174 -
4th 6 162 -
4th 176 -
3rd Place points
Dancer Judge
1 Judge
2 1 65 75 2 100 56 3 75 100 4 56 53 5 53 60 6 60 65 These are added and
the places allocated from here
Dancer Judge
1 Judge
2 Total
Place 1 65 75 140 Third 2 100 56 156
Second 3 75 100 175 First 4 56 53 109 Sixth 5 53 60 113 Fifth 6 60 65 125 Fourth
You can observe a few things from
this. A First and a second beats getting a first and a third, that's obvious,
But when you have three judges funny things happen, like a dancer given one
first place and two eleventh places, will beat a dancer that gets three fourth
places. The system is designed to separate the field so no-one wins by just
a mark or two. If there is a tie for a place the
next place is not awarded. If you would like a print out of
the place points awarded to each place a copy is available
here.
Other odd things are ties. If a judge gives a tie for first place they don't
both get 100, they share the points available for first and second (100+75 divided
by 2) and get 87.5 points each. Therefore when a judge gives the same mark for
two or three dancers further down the placings the same thing happens. A tie
for fifteenth place, they share 36 and 35 points, so they get 35.5 points.
Note: This doesn't apply to North America where theoretically you can have fifteen
people in the National Top Ten.Back to Irish
Dancing in Sydney
© 2000 Amanda Finneran. Reproductions possible on request.